Tsukada Lab. Computer Network Group

Enhancing Reliability in Infrastructure-based Collective Perception: A Dual-Channel Hybrid Delivery Approach with Real-Time Monitoring

Yu Asabe, Ehsan Javanmardi, Jin Nakazato, Manabu Tsukada, Hiroshi Esaki

IEEE Open Journal of Vehicular Technology, vol. 5, pp. 1124–1138, Aug 30, 2024

Summary in three lines

  • Extends AutowareV2X (VTC2023-Spring) into a journal article and formalizes dual-channel hybrid delivery, which keeps the freshest Collective Perception Message by comparing ReferenceTime values.
  • Monitors the packet delivery rate (PDR) of messages from roadside units in real time; Wi-Fi PDR/RSSI and LTE acceptance-rate heatmaps show LTE filling in where one channel degrades.
  • Dual-channel delivery clearly improves the PDR over Wi-Fi alone while keeping end-to-end latency at about 30 ms.

Figures from the paper

Figure 2: System design and architecture: Autoware (left) connected to the AutowareV2X module and its ETSI ITS protocol stack (right).
Figure 2. System design and architecture: Autoware (left) connected to the AutowareV2X module and its ETSI ITS protocol stack (right).Source: Figure 2 from Asabe et al., IEEE OJVT 2024 (© 2024 The Authors, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0, original artwork from the authors’ manuscript)AutowareV2X runs as a separate ROS 2 node beside the Autoware driving stack and exchanges messages such as CPMs over wireless links, so the driving software can use shared perception data without being modified.
Figure 4: Dual-channel hybrid delivery: CPMs are sent over a direct V2I link (Channel 1) and over the cellular network (Channel 2) at the same time.
Figure 4. Dual-channel hybrid delivery: CPMs are sent over a direct V2I link (Channel 1) and over the cellular network (Channel 2) at the same time.Source: Figure 4 from Asabe et al., IEEE OJVT 2024 (© 2024 The Authors, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0, original artwork from the authors’ manuscript)When the direct Wi-Fi/802.11p link is blocked or lossy, the same perception message still reaches the vehicle through the cellular network, which is the redundancy the paper proposes.
Figure 16: Packet delivery rate over time for dual-channel CPMs versus Wi-Fi-based CPMs in the field test.
Figure 16. Packet delivery rate over time for dual-channel CPMs versus Wi-Fi-based CPMs in the field test.Source: Figure 16 from Asabe et al., IEEE OJVT 2024 (© 2024 The Authors, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0, original artwork from the authors’ manuscript)In sections A and B the Wi-Fi delivery rate drops below 0.6, while dual-channel delivery stays near 0.7 or higher: the cellular channel fills the gaps where Wi-Fi degrades.

Abstract

Standalone autonomous vehicles primarily rely on their onboard sensors and may have blind spots or limited situational awareness in complex or dynamic traffic scenarios, leading to difficulties in making safe decisions. Collective perception enables connected autonomous vehicles (CAVs) to overcome the limitations of standalone autonomous vehicles by sharing sensory information with nearby road users. However, unfavorable conditions of the wireless communication medium it uses can lead to limited reliability and reduced quality of service. In this paper, we propose methods for increasing the reliability of collective perception through real-time packet delivery rate monitoring and a dual-channel hybrid delivery approach. We have implemented AutowareV2X, a vehicle-to-everything (V2X) communication module integrated into the autonomous driving (AD) software Autoware. AutowareV2X provides connectivity to the AD stack, enabling end-to-end (E2E) experimentation and evaluation of CAVs. The Collective Perception Service (CPS) was also implemented, allowing the transmission of Collective Perception Messages (CPMs). Our proposed methods using AutowareV2X were evaluated using actual hardware and vehicles in reallife field tests. Results have indicated that the E2E network latency of the perception information sent is around 30 ms, and the AD software can use shared object data to conduct collision avoidance maneuvers. The dual-channel delivery of CPMs enabled the CAV to dynamically select the best CPM from CPMs received from different links, depending on the freshness of their information. This enabled the reliable transmission of CPMs even when there was significant packet loss on one of the transmitting channels.

Video

Related video: AutowareV2X: Reliable V2X Communication and Collective Perception for Autonomous Driving

Related video: Extending Autoware for Cooperative Driving: Integrating Perception, Planning, and Coordination

Code

Related research and software

How to cite

Y. Asabe, E. Javanmardi, J. Nakazato, M. Tsukada, and H. Esaki, “Enhancing Reliability in Infrastructure-based Collective Perception: A Dual-Channel Hybrid Delivery Approach with Real-Time Monitoring,” IEEE Open Journal of Vehicular Technology, vol. 5, pp. 1124–1138, 2024, doi: 10.1109/OJVT.2024.3443877.

BibTeX

@article{Asabe2024,
  title         = {Enhancing Reliability in Infrastructure-based Collective Perception: A Dual-Channel Hybrid Delivery Approach with Real-Time Monitoring},
  author        = {Yu Asabe and Ehsan Javanmardi and Jin Nakazato and Manabu Tsukada and Hiroshi Esaki},
  doi           = {10.1109/OJVT.2024.3443877},
  issn          = {2644-1330},
  year          = {2024},
  date          = {2024-08-30},
  urldate       = {2024-08-30},
  journal       = {IEEE Open Journal of Vehicular Technology},
  volume        = {5},
  pages         = {1124--1138},
  abstract      = {Standalone autonomous vehicles primarily rely on their onboard sensors and may have blind spots or limited situational awareness in complex or dynamic traffic scenarios, leading to difficulties in making safe decisions. Collective perception enables connected autonomous vehicles (CAVs) to overcome the limitations of standalone autonomous vehicles by sharing sensory information with nearby road users. However, unfavorable conditions of the wireless communication medium it uses can lead to limited reliability and reduced quality of service. In this paper, we propose methods for increasing the reliability of collective perception through real-time packet delivery rate monitoring and a dual-channel hybrid delivery approach. We have implemented AutowareV2X, a vehicle-to-everything (V2X) communication module integrated into the autonomous driving (AD) software Autoware. AutowareV2X provides connectivity to the AD stack, enabling end-to-end (E2E) experimentation and evaluation of CAVs. The Collective Perception Service (CPS) was also implemented, allowing the transmission of Collective Perception Messages (CPMs). Our proposed methods using AutowareV2X were evaluated using actual hardware and vehicles in reallife field tests. Results have indicated that the E2E network latency of the perception information sent is around 30 ms, and the AD software can use shared object data to conduct collision avoidance maneuvers. The dual-channel delivery of CPMs enabled the CAV to dynamically select the best CPM from CPMs received from different links, depending on the freshness of their information. This enabled the reliable transmission of CPMs even when there was significant packet loss on one of the transmitting channels.},
  keywords      = {ITS},
  pubstate      = {published},
  tppubtype     = {article}
}